Monday, January 10, 2011

PFA RULINGS IN FAVOUR OF PROSECUTION-PART-I

1

A.P. H.C.-2003 Crl.L.J.2797

S.16-A-Summary trial of case-reg.
2
Delhi H.C. 2002-Crl.L.J.3529
S.16(1-A)-warrant procedure-reg.
3
Madras H.C 1987 LW Crl 342
Institution-not taking cognizance.
4
P&H H.C.-2000(2) FAC 235
Non.examn of Ind.witnes-not fatal
5
All.H.C-1988 Crl.L.J-1245
S.10(7)-F.I. should call-not necessary to examine such witness
S.20-Application of mind-reg.
6
M.P H.C-1990(2)FAC 227
F.I-not corroborated by other witnesses-acquittal cannot be upheld.
Sentence-it is now open to the Court impose lesser punishment.
7
P&H H.C. FAC 1992(1) -121
Stirring of milk not mentioned in complaint- held no particular from prescribed for Crl.Complaint.
8
MAD. H.C-FAC 1992(1)-107
Polythene bag suitable container.
9
H. P.  H.C-FAC1992(1)-145
Neither the Act nor the Rule define ‘other suitable container’
10
MAD. H.C.-FAC 1992(1)-305
No mens rea need be proved.
11
S.C. –1996(2) L.W.Crl.502
Qualification of F.I. can’t be challenged in collateral proceeding
12
S.C.- Recent Crl.Reports-817
S.20A-impleading manufacturers-necessary conditions to implead
13
GUJ. H.C.-1999(1) FAC-243
S.14&19(2)-it is for the vendor to prove that he purchased the article with warranty.
R.14 to 18-it is enough that F.I deposes that he followed. Panch witness corroboration not necessary
14
Orissa H.C-1999 Crl. L.J-1191
Delay in prosecution-petitioners themselves causing delay in filing requisites to send the sample to CFL-Proceedings could not be quashed.
15
  P&H H.C.-2001(2) FAC 110
Validity of R.32(e) & (f)    (Ref. S.No. 59 also)
16
Gujarat H.C.-2001(2) FAC 134
1.Law does not require that bottles should be sterilized
2. Sanctioning authority may prescribe form for  sanction.
17
Orissa H.C.-2001(2) FAC 159
S.10(7)-Ind. Witness not examined –F.I. has no power to compel a witness to be present.
18
Bombay H.C-2001(2)FAC 190

Sentence cannot be reduced.

19
Rajasthan H.C-2001(2)FAC 194

Sale to F.I. is a sale.

2 comments:

sakthi said...

very interesting and most valuable rulings to the food inspectors to conduct PFA cases effectively .thanks a lot.

FOOD said...

Wait and see the forthcoming parts of this post. This blog will be fully dedicated for the improvement of the Food Inspectors' career.